Gravity / The quantum question
On the lattice’s own clock, some waves grow every tick.
A sum over the lattice’s geometries in real time is a quantum theory only if it defines an evolution, and the ledger has a clock: record time, the number of postings so far. Each tick multiplies a wave by a fixed factor, its root w. A one-particle quantum theory with real frequencies needs a positive norm that every tick keeps, so every physical root must lie on the unit circle. At κ = 1 one physical solution of the graviton field grows by √2 every tick, so no such norm exists.
The growing solutions: provedκ = 1: identifiedA norm the tick keeps: open
- Massless scalar of the one-loop model
- Graviton field: the growing solution
Live · roots solved in your browser
1, identified
- Tick
- 0record ticks run
- Graviton
- ×√2per tick, after 0 ticks
- Scalar
- ×2.653per tick at most, after 0 ticks
A wave wtv, with t the record count, is multiplied by its root w at each tick. On the circle a wave turns and keeps its size; outside it grows, inside it fades. The radius is logarithmic: each ring is a factor of 2.
What is drawn. All eight record-time roots of the scalar on the record line, from its symbol s(w) = (2 − y)(4 − βy²(y + 2)) with y = w + 1/w and β = κ/(4κ − 1), solved here at the κ you choose: w = 1 twice, two roots on the circle and four off it. Four stay off the circle at every κ above ½, so record-time growth does not single out a value of κ. For the graviton field the figure shows the growing solution at κ = 1 and its partner 1/√2, and at κ = 3/2 the factor (1 + √10)/3 and its inverse; its other record-time roots are not drawn. The black-hole paper reports, for the lattice scalar’s evolution in record time, solutions that grow by about 2.65 per rank (numerical), the size of the largest root here at κ = 1, and reads that instability, not Hawking emission, as what decides its question of radiation after a collapse (an inference; Target 5.7).
Quantum gravity paper, Theorem 8.1; record-time paper, Theorems 3.2 and 3.4; earlier paper, Proposition 6.16; black-hole paper, Section 5 and Target 5.7
With JavaScript on, this figure solves the record-time roots live. At κ = 1 the graviton field has a solution that grows by √2 per tick; the massless scalar of the one-loop model has four roots off the unit circle at every κ above ½, the largest of size 2.653 at κ = 1 (computed here from the paper’s symbol).
The growing solution
√2 per tick, exactly.
At κ = 1 the linearized Regge equation, the lattice’s equation for a weak gravitational field, has a solution that is the same at every point of a slice of constant record count, so it fits a torus of any size, and is multiplied by √2 at every tick. Four of its fifteen edge components are nonzero, with exact values in √2.
- 1000
- 0100
- 1100
- 0010
- 1010
- 0110
- 1110
- 0001
- 1001
- 0101
- 1101
- 0011
- 1011
- 0111
- 1111
Live · checked in your browser
- Equation
- …largest entry of B(1/√2)u, with the entries of B up to 1.74
- Field
- …the same for the field at the vertex, at w = √2
- Gauge
- …of its length lies outside the four vertex moves at this phase
Checking
Your browser builds the Bloch matrix B of the flat κ = 1 Hessian from Appendix B of the earlier paper, at the phases (w, w, w, w), and applies it to the paper’s polarization u. The paper proves more than the last check shows: the field is no vertex move of any shape, at every spatial period.
Quantum gravity paper, Theorem 8.1 and Appendix A.3; record-time paper, Theorem 3.2
Why no norm survives
A kept norm would equal twice itself.
Suppose a size n(h) of solutions were positive on every physical solution, every one that is not a vertex move, scaled as n(ch) = |c|² n(h), and unchanged by the tick. The tick sends this solution h to √2 h, so n(h) = n(√2 h) = 2 n(h), which forces n(h) = 0. So no such norm exists at any spatial period. The same holds for the solutions the native path sum keeps, with every posting held fixed, for every phase whose Gaussian field equation is a nonzero multiple of Regge’s, and at κ = 3/2 with the factor (1 + √10)/3.
Quantum gravity paper, Theorem 8.1 and Proposition 8.2; record-time paper, Theorems 3.4 and 3.5
The doublers
Record time keeps the four doublers.
Ordering the path sum by record time does not remove the massless corner doublers. Near each axis corner, for every time direction of the long-wave graviton’s cone, some spatial direction carries two real record-time frequencies and other directions none: the doubler propagates in record time with a mixed spectrum.
The four doublers, solved live
Quantum gravity paper, Theorem 3.2
A weight is a damping
Damping of fourth order vanishes in the continuum limit.
A real weight in the sum over geometries enters the record-time equation as a damping, and with the weight derived from the ledger’s cost of curvature the lattice equation is not record-time stable once it has a physical wave away from the zero wave. A weaker test asks only that every family of waves whose roots approach the circle as the spacing shrinks grow by a vanishing amount per unit of physical time. Damping of fourth order in the wave number, the order of the derived weight, passes; damping of second order, the order of the action, fails.
- Fourth order, m = 2
- Second order, m = 1
Live · exact, the model of Section 5.1
0.0100
1.00
- Fourth
- …growth per unit time|w| − 1 = … per tick
- Second
- …growth per unit time|w| − 1 = … per tick
The model. h(x + e0) + h(x − e0) − 2h(x) + ℓh(x) − icℓmh(x) = 0: a record-time wave equation with a spatial Laplacian ℓ and a real damping of order ℓm. A wave of physical momentum q at spacing b has ℓ = 4 sin²(bq/2), and its record factor solves w + 1/w = 2 − ℓ + icℓm. One tick is a time b, so the growth per unit time is log|w|/b. It is a stand-in for a weighted equation, not the derived operator.
Record-time paper, Section 5.1 and Theorem 5.3
With JavaScript on, this figure computes the damped model’s growing root at every spacing. With damping of fourth order the growth per unit time falls like c b²q³/2; with damping of second order it levels off at about 0.455 q for c = 1, which is 2¼ sin(π/8) from the paper’s ω² ≈ ℓ(1 − ic) (computed here).
The derived weight
With the derived weight, the roots are stable in the continuum limit.
At every fixed nonzero strength of the weight built from the ledger’s cost of curvature, every family of physical waves away from the zero wave stays off the circle, and near the zero wave each physical root grows per tick by at most a constant times the cube of its spatial momentum. So the weighted Gaussian equation is stable in the continuum limit, though not on the lattice. This is a statement about roots, not a norm-preserving evolution: no positive physical Hilbert space is constructed. It holds at Gaussian order and rests on κ = 1, the weight’s two identifications and its channel counts. That the lattice-scale modes off the circle leave the continuum theory alone is an inference; for specified two-point observables the record-time paper proves an estimate to that effect, whose independent verification is not yet finished.
Record-time paper, Section 6; quantum gravity paper, Section 8.1
Without a weight
The bare doublers fail even the weaker test.
Without a weight, near the corner πe0 the κ = 1 equation has an exact family of physical solutions on a decaying branch, each multiplied by at most e−3/4 per unit physical time however small the spacing. That rate does not vanish as the spacing shrinks, so the bare equation is not stable in the continuum limit. Its proof is complete; its independent verification is not yet finished.
Record-time paper, Theorem 5.4
Beyond record time
The sum, the graviton and the four demands.
With a stated regulator the path sum is a finite integral; the regulator is stated, not derived. Each requirement, with its status and the sum along a ray live: A finite sum over geometries.
In the stated one-loop diagram model the native graviton is not massless, and an action from the ledger that makes it massless is the precise open target.
How each of the four demands on a quantum theory of gravity stands, with what it rests on: where it stands.
Finite-path-sum paper, Section 1 and Table 1; quantum gravity paper, Theorem 3.3 and Target 6.8
Papers cited: the quantum gravity paper, the finite-path-sum paper, the record-time paper, the earlier paper and the black-hole paper (full titles).
Words on this page, in plain terms: tick · unitarity · record time · record-time root · doubler · path sum · curvature weight · one-loop diagram model.
The gravity portal · The four doublers · Next: what a horizon records · One loop in the full account · Run the checks · Glossary · Search every page