== couplings at M_Z == alpha_em^-1 = 127.951, sin^2 = 0.23121 alpha1^-1(GUT-norm) = 59.0205 alpha2^-1 = 29.5836 alpha3^-1 = 8.4818 == one-loop g1=g2 crossing (sin^2 = 3/8 by construction) == t* = ln(mu/M_Z) = 25.453 mu* = 1.033e+13 GeV == one-loop sin^2 theta_W at canonical scales == mu = 9.119e+01 GeV : sin^2 = 0.23121 mu = 1.000e+03 GeV : sin^2 = 0.24330 mu = 1.000e+06 GeV : sin^2 = 0.27972 mu = 1.000e+09 GeV : sin^2 = 0.31862 mu = 1.000e+12 GeV : sin^2 = 0.36026 mu = 1.000e+13 GeV : sin^2 = 0.37479 mu = 1.000e+14 GeV : sin^2 = 0.38968 mu = 1.000e+15 GeV : sin^2 = 0.40493 mu = 1.000e+16 GeV : sin^2 = 0.42056 mu = 1.000e+17 GeV : sin^2 = 0.43658 mu = 1.033e+13 GeV : sin^2 = 0.37500 == two-loop g1=g2 crossing (sin^2 = 3/8) == mu* = 1.089e+13 GeV sin^2 at mu* = 0.37500 (should be 0.375) == two-loop sin^2 theta_W at canonical scales == mu = 9.119e+01 GeV : sin^2 = 0.23121 mu = 1.000e+03 GeV : sin^2 = 0.24314 mu = 1.000e+09 GeV : sin^2 = 0.31815 mu = 1.000e+13 GeV : sin^2 = 0.37445 mu = 1.000e+14 GeV : sin^2 = 0.38940 mu = 1.000e+15 GeV : sin^2 = 0.40473 mu = 1.000e+16 GeV : sin^2 = 0.42045 mu = 1.000e+17 GeV : sin^2 = 0.43658 ================================================================ VERDICT (panel criterion: mu* in GUT window 1e15 - 1e17 GeV) ================================================================ 1-loop: sin^2=3/8 reached at 1.033e+13 GeV -> OUTSIDE [1e15,1e17] 2-loop: sin^2=3/8 reached at 1.089e+13 GeV -> OUTSIDE [1e15,1e17] IR anchor 3/(4pi) = 0.238732414637843 UV anchor 3/8 = 0.375 == same test, MSSM beta functions (b1=33/5, b2=1) == g1=g2 (sin^2=3/8) at mu* = 2.013e+16 GeV -> INSIDE [1e15,1e17] => the crossing scale is dominated by the (unknown) BSM content, not by cube geometry.